The dreaded Home Report

I have read with interest some recent articles in the press regarding Home Reports.  Given that they have now been in place for over 12 months I found it very interesting that this debate is still continuing and perhaps more vociferously than it did at the time the idea was first mooted.  As a practising Solicitor with considerable experience in the property market I can honestly say that I have never come across a notion that has been so ill conceived and ill thought out as the Home Report.  It benefits no-one apart from Surveyors – apologies to all my friends who are Surveyors, although I fear that they themselves may come a cropper when the panels or nationals take control of the provision of Home Reports at the same cost to the client, taking considerable profit themselves and squeezing the Surveyors into providing Home Reports for much lower costs.

Home Reports were supposed to speed up the process – they haven’t – it now takes a lot longer to get the property on the market.  They were supposed to give a prospective purchaser more knowledge about a property at an earlier part of the process – they don’t.  Purchasers are people who rely on professionals, i.e. Solicitors and Surveyors, to guide them.  The Home Report is poorly laid out and the Solicitor is at a disadvantage not being able to speak to the Surveyor to get his comments by way of verbal report.  There is still the question of how much influence a seller or selling Solicitor has over a Surveyor.  There is a huge conflict of interest in the process in that the Surveyor is being instructed by the seller who is paying his fees but his report is being relied on by a purchaser.

Never mind the increased cost, the delay, the varying valuations, the Home Report was a concept that was not required.  Offers subject to survey worked fine – everyone knew where they were, prospective purchasers were taking advice from professionals who were able to give them guidance regarding values, banks felt more comfortable relying on surveys instructed after offers and if you were a seller who required to get their house on the market due to financial difficulties you are not being prejudiced by the expense of the Home Report.

A plea to the Scottish Government…

Please take a brave decision and scrap this silly scheme.

Home Reports – Your View:

3 thoughts on “The dreaded Home Report”

  1. Robert
    I agree with you re the EPC – total waste of money. Needed to comply with EU regualtions.

    In relation to house purchase don’t be discouraged – I am surprised re the denying of access to home report.

  2. Propertybuyer/seller

    I have not bought or sold a property since these home reports came in, partly due to the market conditions, however I have looked at a couple of possible “private” sales which can go forward without a home report but still require an energy efficiency report done buy a surveyor costing £100 which is a total con if the house you are buying is in need of a total refurb, then you need to go and get the job done again when you re-sell and then renew it every 6 months thereafter.(great if you are a surveyor)

    I have also been refused access to a home report for a house up for sale with an estate agent because I had not made an appointment to view, even though I have been around and looked at the property from the outside.

    my view is that the new rules and the made up ones (by estate agents and surveyors) have helped to stagnate and confuse the market more than ever on top of the recession and I am not likely to be purchasing again anytime soon.

  3. I think theoretically Home Reports seemd like a great idea. Sadly I do not believe the reality has been a success for either buyers or sellers. The inclusion of a survey price is the most important and damaging part.

    The great thing about the Scottish market was the way the market dictated property sales. It was up to the Buyer and Seller to strike a deal/price that pleased them both. The number of property viewings must surely be down as properties are now judged purely on paper, on areas which (if most of us were honest) would not have previously influenced our viewing/buying decision.

    The Home Report has taken the heart and emotion out of buying a home. Whatever happened to getting ‘that feeling’ from a property viewing and allowing our hearts to make decisions about where we want to live?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s